We are guilty of not speaking up about October 6 events/conditions and using all civic engagements possible to defend the rights of Palestinians against the brutal occupation. That is true in Gaza (open air prison) and true in the West Bank (massacres and detention of civilians without any fair trials). This operation of ethnic cleansing has not stopped since 1948 as mentioned in Ilan Pappe’s book.
We are also guilty of not having enough conversation with Israeli population through all means possible. Most of those people were born after 1948, and only those who specialize in history or human rights get to see the out of the box context. Otherwise , the majority are unaware or in denial of what is happening (this is also true of Americans and many other nations). They seem to be receiving propaganda and twisted history in their education. Besides, life is good, so like most the population of planet earth “why should I care?”. That was a conclusion from Gideon Levy. Perhaps we should find ways to have conversations with open minded people.
After seeing “Israelism” documentary and reading couple of articles/books from genuine Israeli scholars, I can tell that the truth will never be buried and there is hope to change the perception of the masses in denial in Israel. But if their intellectuals cannot accept the truth-seeking challenge about history, their government and leaders agenda, then it is a long way before we all realize the losses.
Since October 7 events, It has been interesting to see the amount of propaganda and tension all over news and social media. It is also scary to see how much people believe in propaganda and false marketing. It is also scary to see the amount of hatred spreading. I believe it is going to get much worse moving forward. I have to say that I’m shocked and worried to know that >80% of Israel population support the crimes done by IDF. Yet at the same time they want to revolt against the failures of their leaders.
Nonetheless, getting overwhelmed by the misinformation/propaganda over screens and social media is a signal and alarm to intellectuals that we have a serious obligation to explore, question things, establish meaningful debates, civic engagement, and repurpose our critical thinking and other skills that makes us successful in our careers. We use them to filter lies and unreasonable biases and present solid arguments to the masses. We also have to play devils advocate to see the other sides.
Also, If someone convinced you that speaking up about crimes against humanity is not professional, it is far from truth and far from the integrity required for success in your career.
We also need to have a thick skin. So as things get worse, Stay strong!
My advice to myself is:
1. When you use credible resources, people can change their minds.
2. Always look at the majority of the population as people to sympathize with. Some people are victims of their own media brainwash .. some people are victims of their miserable daily life conditions. So, we have to take the context very carefully and broadly.
3. One has to understand that media labels applied to a whole population does not help any meaningful discussion.
4. No country or government is above criticism, and it does not help to start labeling people as “antisemitic” or “anti American” or “anti anything” to shutdown debate and free speech.
I hope to focus on the root of all these disasters and in my mind it is how the US is ruled. The obsession of the powerful and wealthy about liberal hegemony and concentration of more wealth/power.
The claimed US democracy is partially sound but it has been a wide cover for the wealthy in power to create more wealth. Unfortunately this is not a disease of just US democracy, it is everywhere. That to be continued…